Heat Pump or Furnace + AC: Which System Works Better in Savannah?

by | Feb 24, 2026 | Blog

What Performs Best in Savannah’s Climate

Most HVAC advice and guidelines are written for broad areas across several U.S. climates.

But in Savannah, we have a hot, humid subtropical environment with mild winters, lots of humidity, salt exposure near the coast, and varying shoulder seasons. Your system choice in Savannah is climate-driven.

At Byrd Heating & Air, we evaluate performance based on how equipment behaves in Savannah conditions.

How Each System Works

Heat Pump

A heat pump transfers heat instead of creating it.

  • In cooling mode, it removes heat from indoors
  • In heating mode, it extracts heat from outdoor air and moves it inside

Efficiency ratings:

  • SEER2 (cooling)
  • HSPF2 (heating)

In Savannah’s typical 40–60°F winter range, heat pumps maintain a Coefficient of Performance (COP) between 2.5 and 3.5. That means for every unit of electricity consumed, it produces 2.5–3.5 units of heat.

There is no combustion or gas. One system handles both heating and cooling.

Read More: Heat Pump Installation by Byrd

Furnace + AC

A traditional split system uses two separate systems and two fuel sources.

  • AC unit for cooling (SEER2 rated)
  • Gas furnace for heating (AFUE rated)

Furnaces create heat through combustion. Even high-efficiency 96% AFUE models still lose energy through exhaust.

Furnaces deliver hotter air quickly, but that output is designed for colder climates than ours.

Read More: Air Conditioning Services

Why Savannah’s Climate Changes the Decision

1. Mild Winters (Mostly)

Savannah sees:

  • Few freezes
  • Limited hours below 30°F
  • Long stretches between 40–60°F

Heat pumps operate extremely efficiently in this range. Furnaces are rarely pushed hard enough to justify combustion-based heating as the primary system.

2. High Humidity

Humidity control drives comfort in Savannah more than raw temperature.

Heat pumps often run longer, lower-speed cycles. That improves moisture removal and indoor stability.

Result:

  • Better comfort
  • Lower mold risk
  • Less temperature swing

3. Energy Cost Structure

In Georgia, electricity pricing is mostly stable but the cost of natural gas fluctuates.

Because heat pumps produce multiple units of heat per unit of electricity, operating costs are typically lower here compared to gas heating.

4. Coastal Corrosion

Living so close to the ocean causes salt exposure which accelerates equipment wear.

Heat pumps run year-round, so coil coatings and build quality matter. Modern coated coils and variable-speed systems outperform older aluminum designs in coastal zones.

This is where equipment selection matters and even equipment replacements for older systems.

What You’ll Feel in the Home

Heat Pump Comfort

  1. Steady, even warmth
  2. Discharge air typically 90–105°F
  3. Fewer temperature swings
  4. No combustion byproducts

The heat feels gentler but consistent.

Furnace Comfort

  1. Hotter discharge air
  2. Faster temperature rise
  3. Stronger initial heat

In Savannah’s mild winters, that rapid cycling can create warm-cool swings some homeowners dislike.

Efficiency Comparison

Heat Pump

COP: 2.5–3.5 in Savannah winters
Produces more heat energy than it consumes in electricity.

Furnace

Maximum efficiency limited by combustion physics.
Even 96% AFUE loses heat through exhaust.

In a climate with limited heating hours, that tradeoff often favors heat pumps.

Installation and Operating Costs

Upfront Cost

Heat Pump:

  • Slightly higher initial investment
  • Replaces both AC and furnace

Furnace + AC:

  • Lower cost if replacing only one component

If both systems are aging, heat pumps typically make more financial sense.

Operating Cost in Savannah

In most cases:

  • Lower winter bills
  • Reduced summer energy use with variable-speed systems
  • Fewer combustion-related repairs

Heat pumps align with our climate load profile.

Lifespan

  • Heat Pump: 12–15 years in coastal conditions
  • Furnace: 15–20 years
  • AC: 12–15 years

Proper maintenance significantly impacts your system’s lifespan.

What About Cold Snaps?

Savannah does see occasional freezes and standard heat pumps may use auxiliary heat near 32°F.
High-performance variable-speed systems maintain efficiency down to roughly 17°F.

Dual Fuel Option

Heat pump handles most heating.
Gas furnace activates only during rare cold snaps.

For some homes, this offers optimal efficiency and comfort balance.

Which System Makes the Most Sense?

Heat Pump Fits Best If You Want:

  1. Lower long-term operating costs
  2. Strong humidity control
  3. One system for heating and cooling
  4. Technology aligned with Savannah’s climate

Furnace + AC Makes Sense If You:

  1. Prefer very hot discharge air
  2. Have poor insulation or older ductwork
  3. Already rely heavily on natural gas
  4. Want dual-fuel capability

The Reality in Savannah

Most modern, well-insulated Savannah homes perform better and cost less to operate with a properly sized, variable-speed heat pump.

What Most Savannah Homeowners Do Next

  • Ask for a price comparison between a heat pump and furnace system
  • Find out which option will lower monthly energy bills
  • Get a clear recommendation based on their home’s size and insulation
  • Decide whether comfort or upfront cost matters more
  • Schedule an in-home evaluation

Matching the right technology to Savannah’s conditions is what determines long-term performance.

If you want a system built around data and not assumptions, Byrd Heating & Air will walk you through the numbers clearly so you can make the right call for your home.

Schedule Your Appointment Today Here

Ask Byrd. Your HVAC Authority. 40 Years Serving Savannah.

7 Strange HVAC Noises and What They Mean

Common HVAC Noises and What They Mean Most HVAC problems don’t start with a breakdown.They start with a sound. Here’s a quick guide to the most common HVAC noises and what they usually indicate: Banging or thumping often means a loose or failing internal component...

Why Your House Smells Musty in Winter (And How Byrd Heating & Air Fixes It)

Ask Byrd. Your HVAC Authority. 40 Years Serving Savannah. Every winter, we get calls that start with the same line: “My house smells musty, but it’s winter. How is that even possible?” It’s a fair question. Most people expect musty odors in the summer when humidity is...

How to Prep Your HVAC System for Winter

Winter strains every part of your heating system. A little preparation now prevents breakdowns, inefficiency, and comfort issues later. Here’s how to get ahead before temperatures drop.

3 Furnace Sounds that are Cause for Concern

If your furnace is making unusual sounds, it’s natural to wonder whether it’s a serious issue or just part of normal operation. While every heating system makes some noise, certain furnace noises can indicate worn components, airflow problems, or mechanical failures...

The 6 Most Important Parts of Your HVAC System

Your HVAC system is made up of several key components that all work together to keep your home comfortable year-round. When one part isn’t working properly, it can affect efficiency, comfort, and even lead to unexpected repairs. Understanding the most important HVAC...

Sign Up For HVAC Newsletter, Rebates, and Energy Incentives

Your Name(Required)
Car Cfad Badge 4c Png

Pin It on Pinterest